The time has come yet again for me to offload a multitude of thoughts from my weary heart. I have been on another remarkable adventure in a faraway world, whose memories I’d like to record for future nostalgia.
I am a postdoctoral researcher of mathematics. Up until recently, there were very few people who pursued academia as a profession. Thus one could become a professor right after completion of their PhD. Being a professor is a great job for the creative who value liberty of time and thought. With the burgeoning of the human population came other problems, such as too many researchers and too few positions. This is when postdoctoral positions were birthed – these are the seats one sits in at the station before getting onto a train, except one does not know if they will ever get to actually board the train.
The natural question is: how does one decide who to put on the train? This is where Darwin’s theory of survival of the fittest comes into play. Most positions go to those who have had a consistent (and exceptional) record of research, along with teaching. While this is the most natural metric for “fitness”, I wonder if it tends to filter out those who may be very creative and good at their jobs, but possibly require more time to come up with good research output. The real essence of this unfortunate problem lies in the fact that one cannot fit intelligence and creativity into check boxes. Fitness is often measured in terms of publications of papers. In my mind, a paper is like a stew – the more time you give it to simmer in your head, the better the result. Too much heat or pressure and it might get burnt, too little time and it may be lacking flavor.
In mathematics, for example, it is normal to have a 1 or 2 year postdoc position, in which teaching is often mandatory. It is also expected that the postdoc be done in a university or place having a different mathematical culture compared to the PhD, often in a different city and maybe even country. Precious iittle time is left for research after acclimatizing and acquainting yourself with your new workplace, and running courses. There are also additional factors of exhaustion and pressure which may contribute to low research output. At the end of this journey, several highly educated people are often left without jobs, but also with almost zero self confidence and motivation. Of course, nobody is to blame for this system; I believe it is a natural consequence. In fact, I both admire and pity members of committees who need to make a choice of one person from a pile of highly qualified candidates. George Bernard Shaw once wrote, “Those who can, do; those who can’t, teach”. While I fundamentally disagree with the statement, I also can witness how untrue it is in this uncertain political and economic climate, where one must teach, be a competent researcher, and have a working group in order to be a Professor.
This is my first postdoctoral position. During my PhD, I was already unsure of whether I would like to run this super slow marathon. I considered myself to be very fortunate to have acquired a good postdoc position. I argued that probably being burnt out is why I feel unsure, and this would be a good way for me to decide if I would like to continue my academic journey thereafter. Given that I did not do anything to heal my burnout, it is no wonder that my postdoc has been riddled with mental hurdles and an almost constant battle in my head regarding my life choices. I have often felt this way before, and have also been told by multiple seniors in the field that this is a normal feeling to have at this point of time, given the uncertainty I am dealing with. Each time I have thought of this in the past, I have looked for alternative career options. This time, opportunity presented itself in the form of a chance to get involved in trading. Let me tell you a bit about trading.
Trading consists of answering the following 3 questions: what to buy, when to buy, and when to sell. You could buy stocks, options, futures, currency, commodities etc. Buying and selling can be long term or short term, depending on your goals. The general convention is: lower the time frame, higher the risk, and higher the risk, higher the returns. If one buys a unit, such as a stock, one can calculate the probability of the price of the stock reaching a certain desirable selling point, based on various statistical models.
A challenge is that your model might not be able to tell you the amount of time in which your desired price is reached, it could be in the next 5 seconds, or in the next 2 hours, say. The prices of some tradeable items, such as options, do have an associated time value, which means that, as time increases, the value of the option inherently decreases, thus making it harder to reach the desired higher selling point. Another problem is that your model might require you to make decisions based on several graphical indicators from different time frames. By the time you assimilate and process all this data (which is a real time feed), your desired price might have already passed. The third, and most important factor in taking a decision, is human emotion – waiting for too long even after your desired price has been reached because of greed, not executing a trade because one is frozen in fear, having low self confidence and getting out of a trade before it has completely played out etc. Of course, several intelligent people have built sophisticated algorithms and machinery to deal with this problem of a large influx and processing of data every few milliseconds. However a lot of countries don’t allow automated trading. The final decision lies with the human, and a profitable trade occurs when mind, heart and nervous system collaborate perfectly. This, in my opinion, really highlights the difference between my fairy tale math and real world, real time applications of math. I have never experienced the pounding of my heart like this before, not even when I finished the proof of my final theorem which took me 3 years to complete and earned me my PhD!
To the amateur eye, trading could be no different from gambling. However, if one believes in math, and in the principle of structure inside apparent chaos, trading could be a gold mine. A standard fixed deposit could give you a maximum annual return of 5-7%. Trading could do that in less than a day. Several mathematicians such as James Simons (founder of the hedge fund Renessaince Technologies which had an average annual gross return of 66.1%; he also has an asteroid named after him!) went into trading in order to quench their mathematical curiosity and ended up billionaires.
A word of caution: I am not advocating for or against trading. Several have fallen pray to its traps. I would definitely discourage anybody getting into it without prior training.
Intraday trading, to me, is the complete opposite of research in academia. If research is a stew, trading is an instant pasta. If research is a marathon, trading is a very short high intensity race. The real difference lies in consequences. Pure mathematical research is often akin to a painting; it won’t harm anybody. Trading, (or most applied mathematics), however, can often have extreme implications.
I am glad I got to see this side of things, so I can cancel one more thing off my bucket list. My heart muscles are unfortunately not strong enough to withstand such intense stress, and I fear I would become an adrenaline junkie if I would be in this profession. No, I would much rather prefer to say abstract nonsense that nobody understands and live in my pseudo- intellectual bubble. I still have doubts regarding my academic journey, but that just means there are more adventures waiting out there for me to enjoy.
What I am slowly getting certain of is that no job is ideal. Why should one expect it anyway? An easy life is often a life not well-lived. We are, after all, creatures of vice. Perhaps life is about discovering our vice and what compromises we are ready to make for it, and maybe thats what makes this journey fun.
What do you prefer – slow cooked stews or instant food?